Narrow money part 3- the US

As previously discussed, a rise in narrow money supply might lead to a rise in economic activity for a number of reasons: narrower money supply measures tend to be reserved for near term expenditure and a rise might suggest a move from delaying expenditure (longer term time deposits to shorter term easily accessible accounts) to spending more. 

A rise in narrow money supply may also be a sign that the money multiplier has been expanding in recent months and lending growth has fed back into the banking system (people have more money), likewise implying a) growing economic activity and b) the potential for more expenditure. 

Indeed, personal incomes have been rising of late, although increases have been moderate:

image

As have loans and leases in bank credit, again, albeit modestly in an historical context:

image

But we are not in normal times and we have seen very significant increases in M1 in the US over the last few years that have subsequently proved short term in terms of economic stimulus.  Narrow money supply growth has indeed been on the increase in the last few months.

image

And their components:

image

Please note that the broader measure incorporates institutional money market funds and large denominated time deposits.

Irrespective narrow money supply growth is strong, although this is not fully reflected in the growth in commercial bank liabilities to date – since Jan 2009 M1 has increased by 46% and Commerical bank liabilities by 17%.

image

The increase in commercial bank liabilities has been historically weak:

imageBut

And while on an annual basis, growth in loans and leases has exceeded growth in liabilities:

image

This trend has reversed in shorter term data which means that loan growth has taken a step back and may presage a weakening in activity:

image

And overall, cash balances (high) and loans and leases (low) as a % of total assets remains weak:

image

image

image

The continuing decline in the provision of funds by the shadow banking system may also be playing some role in monetary dynamics:

image

Also the economy remains exposed to cut backs in fiscal expenditure given the still significant level of national income being provided for by government transfer payments:

image

It is not conclusive that high narrow money supply growth implies higher economic activity given the still significant structural domestic and global economic factors.  Nevertheless, there may be enough in the data to stay the Federal Reserve’s hand until we see a deterioration money supply fundamentals.  

Leave a Reply